Kato Kaelin, the former houseguest of O.J. Simpson, has voiced his renewed doubts about whether Simpson acted alone in the 1994 murders of Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman. Kaelin, who testified during Simpson's murder trial, stated in a recent interview that theories presented in the Peacock documentary "OJ’s Accomplice" have caused him to question his long-held belief that Simpson committed the crimes by himself.

Simpson died in 2024 at the age of 76 from metastatic prostate cancer. He was acquitted of the murders in a 1995 criminal trial but was later found liable in a 1997 civil case.

Kaelin told Decider, "I think OJ is 100 percent guilty." However, the documentary's exploration of potential accomplices, including Simpson's friend Charlie Ehrlich and ex-convict Joseph "Joey" Ippolito, has introduced "reasonable doubt" into Kaelin's mind. The documentary points to evidence such as unidentified fingerprints at the crime scene and analyzes Simpson's controversial book "If I Did It," which features a hypothetical accomplice named "Charlie."

Ehrlich and Simpson's former associate A.C. Cowlings, who drove the white Ford Bronco during Simpson's police chase, have denied involvement. Ippolito died in 2006. The documentary includes testimony from a source claiming Ippolito admitted his involvement before his death.

Kaelin, who lived in a guest house on Simpson's property at the time of the murders, admitted that while he previously thought Simpson acted alone, the new theories "raises doubt in my mind." He cited interviews with retired FBI profiler Jim Clemente as a factor in his shifting perspective.

Kaelin, who now hosts a true crime podcast called "One Degree of Scandalous," reflected on how the notoriety from the trial impacted his life. "I became famous, but for all the wrong reasons," he said, expressing his wish that the crimes had never happened and that Brown Simpson and Goldman had lived.

Despite Simpson's death providing a sense of closure for some, Kaelin suggested that "there's never 100 percent closure" regarding the case. "OJ’s Accomplice" is currently available for streaming on Peacock.