The Trump administration's efforts to lease areas of the U.S. seafloor for deep-sea mining are raising significant environmental concerns among residents of American Samoa and the Northern Mariana Islands. These U.S. territories, located thousands of miles from Washington D.C., are facing proposed auctions for seabed areas rich in minerals like nickel, cobalt, manganese, and copper, crucial for technology and defense industries.

The first auction, targeting waters near American Samoa, was scheduled to take place in Thousand Oaks, California. The administration aims to grant 20-year leases for exclusive commercial mining rights, pending further environmental reviews. A second auction is proposed for areas near the Northern Mariana Islands in December.

Opponents, including Sabrina Suluai-Mahuka from American Samoa, argue that deep-sea mining threatens the delicate ocean ecosystems and cultural traditions tied to the sea. "When they ask us for public comments, it always feels like we’re just screaming at a moving train," said David Cabrera, who leads a group advocating for traditional fishing practices in the Northern Marianas.

The minerals sought are concentrated on the ocean floor and volcanic crusts, with mining techniques typically involving underwater vehicles to collect rocks and sediment. Concerns have been raised about the potential impact of debris and sediment plumes on marine life, including fish populations vital to local economies and subsistence.

"If these people are going to be selling our ocean, they’re going to see our faces when they do these bids," Suluai-Mahuka stated, emphasizing the deep connection between the Samoan way of life and the ocean, which is considered sacred. Malouamaua Tuiolosega, representing the ancient governing council of Manu’a in American Samoa, echoed these sentiments, stating, "We lose the ocean, we lose life."

Legal challenges have emerged, with a judge ruling that the government violated the Endangered Species Act by failing to consider the full impacts of a deep-sea mining lease. This ruling cast uncertainty over the auction's proceedings.

The Marine Minerals Administration has stated that initial auctions grant exploration rights only, with further public comment and environmental review required for any testing or commercial mining. However, critics like Zeno Camacho Deleon Guerrero Jr. of the Micronesia Climate Change Alliance express skepticism: "Once you find what you want, you’re going to get it. You’re going to start mining."

Economic promises associated with deep-sea mining, such as job creation and profit sharing, are met with distrust by many residents. While some business leaders, like John Wasko of the American Samoa Economic Development Council, see potential economic benefits, others point to the lack of binding requirements for hiring local workers or sharing revenues with the territories, unlike in offshore oil and gas drilling.

Nathan Ilaoa, director of the American Samoa Department of Marine and Wildlife Resources, highlighted concerns about the potential impact on the territory's tuna fishery and the StarKist cannery, which is the last remaining cannery in American Samoa. The disruption of the ocean floor could affect tuna migratory patterns and lead to the cannery's closure, which would be an economic disaster.

American Samoa previously issued a moratorium on deep-sea mining within its territorial waters, but has limited authority over federal waters beyond three nautical miles. While the governor's office has expressed shifting views, many residents and traditional leaders remain opposed.

Residents of the Northern Mariana Islands, still recovering from recent typhoons and facing fiscal challenges, are also watching closely. Governor David M. Apatang has expressed faith in federal regulations but has requested a pause on the auction pending legal decisions. Kimberlyn King-Hinds, the Republican nonvoting congressional delegate, has introduced legislation to distribute 50% of deep-sea mining revenues to nearby territories.

Cultural navigators like Cecilio Raiukiulipiy worry that deep-sea mining threatens traditional navigation by sea and stars, as well as critical spawning grounds for marine life. "They don’t understand how we live," Raiukiulipiy said of the federal government. "They’re looking at it with a dollar sign. Us, we look at how we’re going to survive, how we are going to live, how we are going to eat."