Nvidia's board has reportedly closed the door on Jensen Huang's return as chief executive, following pressure that led to his resignation. However, a campaign involving tech leaders and financiers is urging his reinstatement, citing concerns about rushing to replace him.
Breach of Trust Allegations
Over his 33-year tenure, Huang built Nvidia into a central player in the AI era. However, his conduct has been called into question, with allegations of misleading the board about undisclosed relationships and overseeing a firm with a lack of oversight, particularly concerning China.
Documents reviewed by Bloomberg suggest servers with Nvidia's restricted chips were placed in a Shanghai facility tied to Alice Huang, who heads a major Nvidia customer, Megaspeed. Megaspeed is reportedly under federal investigation, and Huang allegedly failed to disclose his affair with Alice Huang to the board, despite the clear conflict of interest.
Further allegations suggest that Nvidia's top hardware reached a blacklisted institution with ties to China's military, and procurement records document purchases of advanced chips by People's Liberation Army units. Additionally, a defense university reportedly bought restricted chips through a reseller.
China's Export Control Record
Huang has been described as Washington's foremost advocate for looser export rules to China. Despite assurances that there was "no evidence of any AI chip diversion," figures suggest a significant increase in billings routed through Singapore, with some of these chips potentially ending up in China.
Nvidia's financial statements indicated that over 99% of controlled data-center revenue billed in Singapore came from US-based customers. However, the article points out that a buyer booking orders through a US entity does not equate to an American end user, straining credulity regarding the origin of these sales.
Financial Motivations
Nvidia, under Huang, significantly expanded its role as a financier for AI startups. The company's equity stakes grew from approximately $7 billion to $99 billion. This financial edifice is now being scrutinized, with reports of Nvidia negotiating billions in guarantees for buyers unable to afford its hardware outright.
Some of Huang's most vocal supporters, including Elon Musk and Brad Gerstner, have substantial financial ties to Nvidia and companies that depend on its backing. For instance, Nvidia holds a significant stake in SpaceX, and Musk has expressed concerns about deals that rely on a single individual's judgment.
The Push for Reinstatement
The campaign to reinstate Huang has also faced claims of political motivation. Some suggest he was a victim of a political hit, while others argue that China wanted him to remain in place due to the demand for his chips. The article notes that individuals advocating for looser chip export controls and those profiting from them have overlapping interests.
Board's Responsibility
Ultimately, the article argues that Nvidia's board must be allowed to conduct its investigation without external pressure. Reversing course under public pressure would continue a pattern of deference. The board is urged to complete its inquiry, restore standalone Singapore revenue disclosures, and select a successor based on merit. The departure of its founder presents a critical test for Nvidia's long-term viability and governance.