National Savings & Investments (NS&I) has informed thousands of Premium Bond holders that they must return duplicate prize money that was mistakenly paid into their accounts due to a technical error. The blunder resulted in £518,000 being incorrectly distributed to Direct Saver accounts following May's prize draw.
Approximately 3,500 savers were affected by the error. NS&I contacted these customers to explain that transactions on their accounts were temporarily blocked while the duplicate payments were reversed. While some of the funds were automatically reclaimed, £1,600 still needs to be repaid by customers.
One affected customer reported that his account was frozen after he won £1,700 but received an additional £325 in error. His access was restricted until the overpayment was recovered.
According to The Complaints Resolver's Scott Dixon, customers are not legally entitled to keep money paid in error. However, he stated that NS&I should ensure that customers do not suffer a detriment due to the institution's errors. Dixon advised that if customers have already spent the excess funds, they should not be forced to repay the entire amount immediately. He suggested that NS&I should offer interest-free repayment plans and consider goodwill payments or compensation.
This incident follows a series of previous errors by NS&I. In March 2026, it was revealed that around £475 million belonging to deceased customers had not been distributed to their families, initially believed to affect 37,500 estates. An update in May indicated that this figure had reduced, with an estimate of just under 30,300 estates potentially affected, totaling up to £181.9 million. The former chief executive, Dax Harkins, resigned following this scandal.
In June 2023, NS&I mistakenly paid the wrong interest rate to thousands of savers, leading to overpayments totaling £2 million, with 3,265 individuals receiving an extra £600 each. In that instance, customers were not required to repay the excess funds.