An HR director at Jaguar Land Rover (JLR) had his £4 million discrimination case struck out after the "adversarial" questioning in the tribunal left him too ill to continue.

James Baker, who was Head of HR, Overseas, for JLR, brought a wide range of claims against the company, including disability discrimination, harassment, whistleblowing detriment, and unfair dismissal, alleging he was a victim of "bullying and harassment." He sought compensation exceeding £4 million.

During his initial cross-examination in June, Mr. Baker's blood pressure spiked, leading to an adjournment. His treating psychiatrist indicated that the adversarial nature of the hearing triggered intense symptoms of PTSD and anxiety, causing his blood pressure to surge. The psychiatrist suggested providing Mr. Baker with advance notice of cross-examination topics could help mitigate these symptoms.

However, when the hearing resumed in September, Mr. Baker reportedly "failed/refused to use the (medically recommended) adjustment made for him." After another single day of cross-examination, his blood pressure spiked again, requiring hospitalization.

Birmingham Employment Tribunal heard that the "adversarial approach" contributed to Mr. Baker's health issues. JLR argued that Mr. Baker's medical condition had worsened and that any further adjournment would breach their right to a fair trial due to the "loss of cogency of evidence." While Mr. Baker's legal team proposed alternatives like written questions, Employment Judge Hilary Harding ruled that requiring JLR to provide its cross-examination questions in advance would be a "fundamental interference" with their right to a fair trial, deeming it unreasonable and disproportionate.

Ultimately, the tribunal concluded that a fair trial was no longer possible given the time already lost and the anticipated duration for further legal proceedings. JLR's application to strike out the claim was granted.